Are you better off investing in short-term or long-term rentals? Here are the advantages—and disadvantages—to consider.


Buying a home? Search All Homes
Have any real estate questions? Contact Me

The benefits of real estate investing are numerous, which is why so many people do it. If you’re new to this venture, though, choosing the right strategy can be daunting. Should you invest in a short-term or long-term rental property?

To answer that question, I’ll outline the advantages and disadvantages of each. 

Starting with short-term rentals (such as an Airbnb), the biggest advantage is that it generally brings a higher return on investment. Vacation rentals are also usually marketed on platforms that allow the host (i.e., the investor) to set a unique rental rate. 

The main disadvantage, though, is that short-term rentals are becoming illegal, or at least more strictly regulated, in more and more markets across the U.S. Here in Cincinnati, the licensing ordinance with additional taxes for vacation rentals is currently being debated by the city council. Moreover, even if you’re investing in a location where Airbnb is legal at the moment, there’s no guarantee that situation won’t change in the future.

 

 

“Both short-term and long-term rentals have clear pros and cons, so remember to consider your personal preferences before deciding which option to pursue.”


When it comes to long-term rentals, the biggest advantage is that it provides a sense of stability and predictability. You still have to make sure you screen your tenants well, but if you take care of your property, you can expect them to stick around for a few years. Keep in mind that the laws governing the relationships between landlords and tenants vary from state to state. Some locations favor the former, while others favor the latter. 

Another advantage is that, unlike short-term rentals, the rules and regulations are not changing or becoming stricter. As long as you maintain your property, respond to your tenants’ reasonable requests or concerns, don’t discriminate against them, and pay your taxes diligently, you should stay out of trouble. 

The main disadvantage to long-term rentals is something we already touched on. As I said, the laws governing the relationships between landlords and tenants vary from state to state, but most states favor tenants. 

Even if you apply the most scrutinizing screening process when choosing your tenants, you can still end up with bad ones, and most states restrict the tools you have at your disposal to deal with them. If one of them doesn’t pay rent, you have to give them notice before you can take legal action. 

One of the best things about real estate investing is the diversity of options. Both short-term and long-term rentals have clear pros and cons, so remember to consider your personal preferences before deciding which option to pursue. 

As always, if you have any questions about this or any other real estate topic, don’t hesitate to reach out to me. I’d be happy to help you.